james otis the pre-revolutionist-第7节

按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！


0；000　words。　　Minot's　report　appears　to　have　been　derived　from　Adams'　notes　done　into　full　form　by　an　unknown　writer；　who　probably　put　in　here　and　there　some　rather　florid　paragraphs　of　his　own。　　At　a　subsequent　period；　Adams　took　up　the　subject　and　corrected　Minot's　report；　giving　the　revised　address　to　William　Tudor；　who　used　the　same　in　his　biography　of　James　Otis。　　From　these　sources　we　are　able　to　present　a　fair　abstract　of　what　were　the　leading　parts　of　Otis's　speech。　　In　the　beginning　he　said：　

〃May　it　please　your　Honors：

〃I　was　desired　by　one　of　the　court　to　look　into　the　books；　and　consider　the　question　now　before　them　concerning　Writs　of　Assistance。　　I　have　accordingly　considered　it；　and　now　appear；　not　only　in　obedience　to　your　order；　but　likewise　in　behalf　of　the　inhabitants　of　this　town；　who　have　present　another　petition；　and　out　of　regard　to　the　liberties　of　the　subject。　　And　I　take　this　liberty　to　declare；　that；　whether　under　a　fee　or　not　（for　in　such　a　cause　as　this　I　despise　a　fee）；　I　will　to　my　dying　day　oppose；　with　all　the　powers　and　faculties　God　has　given　me；　all

such　instruments　of　slavery　on　the　one　hand；　and　villainy　on　the　other；　as　this　Writ　of　Assistance　is。

〃It　appears　to　me　the　worst　instrument　of　arbitrary　power；　the　most　destructive　of　English　liberty　and　the　fundamental　principles　of　law；　that　was　ever　found　in　an　English　law…book。　　I　must；　therefore；　beg　your　Honors'　patience　and　attention　to　the　whole　range　of　an　argument；　that　may；　perhaps；　appear　uncommon　in　many　things；　as　well　as　to　points　of　learning　that　are　more　remote　and　unusual；　that　the　whole　tendency　of　my　design　may　the　more　easily　be　perceived；　the　conclusions　better　descend；　and　the　force　of　them　be　better　felt。

〃I　shall　not　think　much　of　my　pains　in　this　case；　as　I　engaged　in　it　from　principle。　　I　was　solicited　to　argue　this　case　as　advocate…general；　and　because　I　would　not；　I　have　been　charged　with　desertion　from　my　office。　　To　this　charge　I　can　give　a　very　sufficient　answer。　　I　renounced　that　office；　and　I　argue　this　case；　from　the　same　principle；　and　I　argue　it　with　the　greater　pleasure；　as　it　is　in　favor　of　British　liberty；　at　a　time　when　we　hear　the　greatest　monarch　upon　earth　declaring　from　his　throne；　that　he　glories　in　the　name　of　Briton；　and　that　the　privileges　of　his　people　are　dearer　to　him　than　the　most　valuable　prerogatives　of　his　crown；　and　it　is　in　opposition　to　a　kind　of　power；　the　exercise　of　which；　in　former　periods　of　English　history；　cost　one　king　of　England　his　head；　and　another　his　throne。

〃I　have　taken　more　pains　in　this　case　than　I　ever　will　take　again；　although　my　engaging　in　this　and　another　popular　case　has　raised　much　resentment。　　But　I　think　I　can　sincerely　declare；　that　I　cheerfully　submit　myself　to　every　odious　name　for　conscience'　sake；　and　from　my　soul　I　despise　all　those　whose　guilt；　malice　or　folly；　has　made　them　my　foes。

〃Let　the　consequences　be　what　they　will；　I　am　determined　to　proceed。　　The　only　principles　of　public　conduct；　that　are　worthy　of　a　gentleman　or　a　man；　are　to　sacrifice　estate；　ease；　health　and　applause；　and　even　life；　to　the　sacred　calls　of　his　country。

〃These　manly　sentiments；　in　private　life；　make　the　good　citizen；　in　public　life；　the　patriot　and　the　hero。　　I　do　not　say　that；　when　brought　to　the　test；　I　shall　be　invincible。　　I　pray　God　I　may　never　be　brought　to　the　melancholy　trial；　but　if　ever　I　should；　it　will　then　be　known　how　far　I　can　reduce　to　practice　principles　which　I　know　to　be　founded　in　truth。　　In　the　meantime；　I　will　proceed　to　the　subject　of　this　writ。〃

After　this　introductory　part　we　are　obliged　to　fall　back　on　the　summary　given　by　Mr。　Adams。　　According　to　his　report；　Otis　in　the　next　place　went　into　fundamentals　and　discussed　the　rights　of　man　in　a　state　of　nature。　　In　this　part；　the　argument　ran　in　an　analagous　vein　to　that　of　Rousseau　in　the　Contrat　Social　that　is；　man　in　the　first　place　is　a　sovereign　subject　only　to　the　higher　laws　revealed　in　his　own　conscience。　　In　this　state　he　has　a　right　to　life；　to　liberty；　to　property。

Here　the　speaker　fell　into　the　manner　of　Jefferson　in　the　opening　paragraphs　of　the　Declaration。　　It　is　to　be　noted　that　Otis　presented　the　truth　absolutely；　he　including　negroes　in　the　common　humanity　to　whom　inalienable　rights　belong。

Mr。　Otis　next　took　up　the　social　compact；　and　showed　that　society　is　the　individual　enlarged　and　generalized。　　This　brought　him　to　the　question　before　the　court；　for　the　conflict　now　on　was　a　struggle　of　society；　endowed　with　inalienable　rights；　against　arbitrary　authority　and　its　abusive　exercise。

The　abusive　exercise　was　shown　in　the　attempts　to　enforce　the　Acts　of　Trade。　　Of　this　kind　was　the　old　Navigation　Act；　and　of　like　character　was　the　Importation　Act。　　It　was　to　enforce　these　that　the　Writs　of　Assistance　had　been　devised。　　Mr。　Otis　then　continued：

〃Your　Honors　will　find；　in　the　old　books　concerning　the　office　of　a　justice　of　the　peace；　precedents　of　general　warrants　to　search　suspected　houses。　　But；　in　more　modern　books；　you　will　find　only　special　warrants　to　search　such　and　such　houses；　specially　named；　in　which　the　complainant　has　before　sworn；　that　he　suspects　his　goods　are　concealed；　and　will　find　it　adjudged；　that　special　warrants　only　are　legal。　　In　the　same　manner；　I　rely　in　it；　that　the　writ　prayed　for　in　this　petition；　being　general；　is　illegal。　　It　is　a　power　that　places　the　liberty　of　every　man　in　the　hands　of　every　petty　officer。

〃I　say；　I　admit　that　special　Writs　of　Assistance；　to　search　special　places；　may　be　granted　to　certain　persons　on　oath；　but　I　deny　that　the　writ　now　prayed　for　can　be　granted；　for　I　beg　leave　to　make　some　observations　on　the　writ　itself；　before　I　proceed　to　other　acts　of　Parliament。

〃In　the　first　place；　the　writ　is　universal；　being　directed　to　'all　and　singular　justices；　sheriffs；　constables；　and　all　other　officers　and　subjects；'　so　that；　in　short；　it　is　directed　to　every　subject　in　the　King's　dominions。　　Every　one；　with　this　writ；　may　be　a　tyrant　in　a　legal　manner；　and　may　control；　imprison；　or　murder；　any　one　within　the　realm。

〃In　the　next　place　it　is　perpetual；　there　is　no　return。　　A　man　is　accountable　to　no　person　for　his　doings。　　Every　man　may　reign　secure　in　his　petty　tyranny；　and　spread　terror　and　desolation　around　him；　until　the　trump　of　the　archangel　shall　excite　different　emotions　in　his　soul。

〃In　the　third　place；　a　person　with　this　writ；　in　the　daytime；　may　enter　all　houses；　shops；　etc。；　at　will；　and　command　all　to　assist　him。

〃Fourthly；　by　this　writ；　not　only　deputies；　etc。；　but　even　their　menial　servants；　are　allowed　to　lord　it　over　us。　　What　is　this　but　to　have　the　curse　of　Canaan　with　a　witness　on　us？　　To　be　the　servant　of　servants；　the　most　despicable　of　God's　creation？

〃Now；　one　of　the　most　essential　branches　of　English　liberty　is　the　freedom　of　one's　house。　　A　man's　house　is　his　castle；　and　whilst　he　is　quiet；　he　is　as　well　guarded　as　a　prince　in　his　castle。　　This　writ；　if　it　should　be　declared　legal；　would　totally　annihilate　this　privilege。　　Custom…house　officers　may　enter　our　houses　when　they　please；　we　are　commanded　to　permit　their　entry。　　Their　menial　servants　may　enter；　may　break　locks；　bars；　and　every　thing　in　their　way；　and　whether　they　break　through　malice　or　revenge；　no　man；　no　court；　can　inquire。　　Bare　suspicion；　without　oath；　is　sufficient。

〃This　wanton　exercise　of　this　power　is　not　a　chimerical　suggestion　of　a　heated　brain。　　I　will　mention　some　facts。　　Mr。　Pew　had　one　of　these　writs；　and；　when　Mr。　Ware　succeeded　him；　he　endorsed　this　writ　over　to　Mr。　Ware；　so　that　these　writs　are　negotiable　from　one　officer　to　another；　and　so　your　Honors　have　no　opportunity　of　judging　the　persons　to　whom　this　vast　power　is　delegated。　　Another　instance　is　this：　　

〃Mr。　Justice　Walley　had　called　this　same　Mr。　Ware　before　him；　by　a　constable；　to　answer　for　a　breach　of　the　Sabbath…day　acts；　or　that　of　profane　swearing。　　As　soon　as　he　had　finished；　Mr。　Ware　asked　him　if　he　had　done。　　He　replied；　'Yes。'　　'Well；　then；'　said　Mr。　Ware；　'I　will　show　you　a　little　of　my　power。　　I　command　you　to　permit　me　to　search　your　house　for　uncustomed　goods；'　and　went　on　to　search　the　house　from　the　garret　to　the　cellar；　and　then　served　the　constable　in　the　same　manner。

〃But　to　show　another　absurdity　in　this　writ；　if　it　be　established；　I　insist　upon　it；　every　person；　by　the　14th　of　Charles　the　Second；　has　this　power；　as　well　as　the　custom…house　officers。　　The　words　are；　'It　shall　be　lawful　for　any　person；　or　persons；　authorized；'　etc。　　What　a　scene　does　this　open。　Every　man　prompted　by　revenge；　ill…humor；　or　wantonness；　to　inspect　the　inside　of　his　neighbor's　house；　may　get　a　Writ　of　Assistance。　　Others　will　ask　it　from　self…defence；　one　arbitrary　exertion　will　provoke　another；　until　society　be　involved　in　tumult　and　in　blood。〃

This　extract　may　serve　to　show　the　Demosthenic　power　of　James　Otis　as　an　orator。　　We　cannot　within　our　limits　present　many　additional　paragraphs　from　his　great　plea　in　the　cause　of　his　countrymen。

To　the　next　division　of　his　argument　he　confuted　the　position　taken　by　Gridley　with　respect　to　the　alleged　legal　precedents　for　the　Writs　of　Assistance。　　He　showed　that　the　writs　were　wholl